Why do we need a Real Democracy Movement?

Gavin says:

We need a written codified constitution that removes parliamentary sovereignty and replaces it with a charter, mandated by referendum, that sets out the core legislative principles that guide the work of Parliament and which Parliament has to abide by. These principles would be no different to moral principles of social, environmental and economic justice that are so absent in todays government.

Within that, must be a protective framework that devolves power to the regions and nations that make up the UK and puts local government on an independent statutory footing beyond the reach of parliament. At the same time it must encourage new participative forms of democracy operative at both the national and local level.

David says:

I think we need to empower the people because the best decisions are made by the many not the few. We also need to encourage democratic pluralism so if one social structure fails there are others available to support our needs. I discuss ways to make this happen now without political change in Fluidity – the way to true Demokratia. The ideas I’ve been working on gel beautifully with RDM and I think we can make a new global democracy without by creating a new currency with embedded tax and welfare. We can also buy back resources and infrastructure and democratise their management.

Fae says:

The RDM is needed more than ever if we are to live, progress and change the system, as it is deeply one sided for the very rich.

Bob says:

In the minds of the “powers than be”, democracy is allowing those aged 18 and above to put a cross in a box every now and again, and too often – in UK terms – at a time of the Government’s choosing. The people deserve more information, more trust and more power over their own lives than simply the occasional right to vote. More (and more) decisions affecting people in local areas need to be taken in local areas, and by the people who live there, not by politicians in a central location in rooms with the doors closed and without any requirement to consult. We deserve more, as the decisions made affect us and how, how well and sometimes whether we live. Representative democracy needs to be completely reconsidered. The Common Weal idea of a Citizens Assembly comprising a representative group of the Scottish population (representative in terms of a wide variety of factors, not just gender and place of residence) as a second chamber appeals to me, but only as one step in the “real democracy” process. Other “all of us first ideas” are necessary: control of local economies and local infrastructure, with people control rather than Government control or – far more commonly and far more worryingly – control by (or at least over-influenced by) transnational corporations. The people need to see that they can change things, that they can do things. Perhaps we need Obama’s “Yes, you can” slogan, but meaning it far far more than he did! We need to stop thinking that our economy – and our purpose in life – all revolves around MONEY rather than community, looking after your neighbour, mutual support, etc. – not only within Scotland and the UK but also all over the world.

Christopher says:
We need to regain & rewrite the narrative & educate people to realise the true purpose of an economy & avoid perpetuating capitalist myths by debunking, explaining & not using terms like Tax & Spend, Government Debt & Paying Down the Deficit.. These abstract concepts are currently misleading & need to be understood more fully & suitably challenged & replaced or more accurately clarified & redefined.

Merline says:
In this time of rising fascism and deepening poverty and ecological crisis, it is more apparent than ever that our interests are doomed to go unheeded within the current system, and our so-called representatives will only steer us further towards disaster. Change can only come through direct democracy led by people not elites.

Andrew says:
RDM is needed because anti-democratic forces are at work and those forces are in the hands of wealthy and powerful owners of Capital.

Amjad says:
Real democracy work with the consent of the common people.

John says:
Democracy is a sort of sharing; a cultural change to a sharing society is now urgently needed in view of the irrational methods used to allocate resources

John says:
We need a grass roots democratic movement to transform the system.

Simon says:
Because we don’t have real democracy. The primary purpose of our sham democracy is to convince us that we do whilst perpetuating what is little more than reinvented slavery.

John says:
The present system almost locks people out of feeling able to be powerful, have a voice that can be heard and paid attention to. People like me need a forum where we can express our views, learn from others and join together to make a difference. I worked as a social worker involved in writing and delivering parenting courses, and I was very struck by just how powerless ordinary people felt–even if this was the Local authority (eg parents with children in care (looked after) usually felt very powerless in the face of Social Work reports. I used to encourage them to write their own reports–which used to impress the Children’s Panel (Scotland’s equivalent to Magistrates Courts), and it built parents’ confidence as well. The process of delivering parenting courses should engage parents’ own expertise as well as offering a forum where they can learn from each other, and from course material and trying things out. It can also act as a way in to Adult or further education. There has been a lot of dis-empowering of parents through Child Protection and juvenile justice, which, while very necessary if we are going to have a system protecting children needs to engage with parents much better than at present–it has got to a situation where social work see their “clients” as “them”, when they are “us”. I’m not trying to excuse abuse–just that the present system (which came in around the time trades unions were neutered, all adds up to council estates becoming alienated from mainstream society–and that’s one reason we have had Brexit (and Trump).

Mark says:
The RDM can play a vital role in stimulating and supporting debate around how to develop a functioning democratic system that works for people and planet.

Anson says:
Transforming our democracy into one that truly represents the genuine interests of our people is a huge priority.

Peter says:
I live in rural France and I have a foot-hold in Essex UK, but am there only very occasionally. Any structure that is open, inclusive, encourages free and autonomous participation, is non-hierarchical and maintains a vigorous self-critique will be a valuable element in a new, equitable and self-sustaining society. Any such structure should have a well-developed ethos that doesn’t rely on organisational cliches, of which democracy may be one and capitalism may be another. Attachment to or aversion from either of these labels is likely to be a hindrance.

France encourages, supports and celebrates community structures and networks at a local, departmental, regional and national level, with a lot of emphasis on culture and the arts. These two dimensions of social life are levelling and sharing. RDM in whatever form it evolves to become, might take a leaf from this book. I think republicanism should have a higher profile: the monarchy perpetuates a pernicious class system and the myth of social mobility, ‘climbing the ladder of success’ and ‘meritocracy’, rule by the cleverest (however they may be defined).

Eoghann says:
There is an evident tendency towards fascism throughout the entire world in which personal rights and liberties are increasingly curtailled or taken away entirely for the profit or further empowerment of a handful of oligarchs. This phenomenon is the source of or a major contributor to many social ills; to name a few, increased disparity between socio-economic classes and increasing poverty, advancing decay of the education system, and the acceleration of environmental degradation which both adversely impacts human health and the economy. In order for there to be an equitable distribution of wealth – in order for there to be a flourishing intellectual life among the people – in order for citizens to be directly in charge of the landscape and resources which rightfully is there own and directly impacts the health of themselves and their progeny, there must be a healthy democracy in place, one in which the people are the champions of politic process and policy rather than powerless by-standers. That is why I think movements like RDM are needed – true democracies are needed in all parts of the world, and I want to do my small part in helping to build them.

Peter says:

Active Citizenship i.e. authentic/real democracy underpins the sustainability of our communities and the planet as a whole. Real Authentic Democracy (RAD-I-Call) should be a, not so radical but, logical movement that is progressed through society with the utmost urgency. Other than personal, day to day well being, I cant think of anything more pressing!

Rosemary says:
I am so fed up with the childish actions of people who we have elected to govern us and the way that corporations can bully institutions into doing their bidding regardless of the consequences to people and the natural world. I believe in the concept of governance where people from all walks of life come together to debate and determine what kind of world we want to be part of. The issues we face today are too important to be left to a few people who think that the survival of their parties are more important than people, communities and the environment.

Catherine says:
As a mother, teacher and woman I want to be part of a shift that will see a brighter future for our Earth.

Peter A says:
Democracy has lost its meaning in our current society. It is the interests of the big global corporations and the banks that drive the policies of government. So we get a top-down set of policies and commands that do not answer the needs of ordinary people; higher productivity, lower wages, unemployment and all the things that come with austerity. The only possible way of transforming this society into one where the power is vested in the people themselves is through building a mass movement from the bottom up, and that has to come from new forms of democratic participation of the majority. People are contemptuous of establishment politics and the vested interests that determine policy. They are receptive to the ideas of new forms of democracy as was seen in Scotland last year. And ideas of giving power to the people are contained within, for example, the fight of the Hillsborough families for real justice, the strikes against the government by the junior hospital doctors and even Leicester City`s football triumph. Unlocking the power of the people through democratic participation…

Pamela says:
5 questions for democracy
It’s time to look out for ourselves and each other, and to build the social and economic landscape anew, because our elected politicians are unwilling and unable to act on behalf of the working majority. The Tory government feels bold enough to bring its unelected, unaccountable corporate cronies into Whitehall to steer policy, and this has to be a warning to us that democracy means nothing to the friends of the 1 per cent. Why is Douglas Gurr, CEO Amazon China now a non-executive director of the DWP?
Remember Tony Benn’s five questions for democracy?

  • “What power have you got?”
  • “Where did you get it from?”
  • “In whose interests do you use it?”
  • “To whom are you accountable?”
  • “How do we get rid of you?”

* Sir Mark Allen and Jack Straw are not being prosecuted by the CPS for their part in the rendition and torture of Abdul Hakim Belhaj and his wife
* Douglas Gurr, CEO Amazon China, is now a non-executive director at the DWP
* Dr. Robert Nowill, ex Technology and Development Director at GCHQ has been appointed to the ‘independent’ review panel headed by David Anderson, QC to look at the bulk powers of the Investigatory Powers Bill
*There is no power of recall relating to Members of Parliament/government ministers
*There are no restrictions governing the revolving door between ex-government ministers/officials and appointments to the private and corporate sector
*Our education system has just been sold off to private enterprise Academy Trusts, including one owned by the former co-founder of Carphone Warehouse. Read the list of trustees for yourselves.


Penny W says:

Bring activists into the debate
So, I’ve been thinking about a focus on this thing called democracy. and whether it’s the hook to hang a way out of all this crap. As part of this, me and my son who lives here (at his suggestion) went to a meeting about the future of democracy organised by Melbourne City Council. I went with enormous cynicism (power is never given stuff), but hoped that Oz might be different from UK. No it’s not! It was filled with not-for-profit policy nerds, and good intentioned civil servants. The only thing that brought it alive were the contributions from community activists working on real issues: refugees, fracking etc. which left me concluding, for myself, that this is the hook that makes a difference. Not a conceptual framework of democracy. But to shape what is needed on a macro level from real issues. From substance comes form. From action comes structures. From concrete concerns comes organising.

I did wonder whether, as part of your next initiative, an explicit focus on bringing activists into the debate might have legs – i.e. what do we conclude about our future governance arrangements from the struggles they are involved in: around health, social care, housing, benefits, employment, planning, climate change etc.


Grattan says:

Sweep away the cobwebs
I fervently support the aims of the Real Democracy Movement. I believe we need to sweep away a few cobwebs, including the monarchy and the House of Lords, so that we can get back to the bone structure of our much ailing democracy. This is a personal view. The Romani movement globally is starting on a democratic transition – introduction of electronic voting, grass-roots democracy that will increase legitimacy, accountability and political clout, while providing a collective mandate and people’s voice that may eventually lay claim to a people’s sovereignty. That, I believe, puts us in the same camp. I already am active as a member of the Corbyn Labour Party and Momentum, picketing with the junior doctors, watching for a chance to help bring the banks, the City, the big corporations, under democratic control, and where useful into nationalisation.


Donald says:

Political system change
We all know the real intentions of Agenda 21. Current political, economic and educations systems, under capitalist doctrines, are stealthily creeping forward with this terrifying programme under our very noses. It is evidenced in many ways, though the most obvious is the deliberate intensifying of wealth concentration – simultaneously with increasing, austerity-caused poverty and numbers of half-starved people forced to use food banks. Political system change is the only effective solution, via the ballot box and/or peaceful revolution. Communication is vital, and the RDM gives us a glimmer of hope in that regard. It is a little step in the right direction, though hopefully with an eventual massive social impact.


Marcelle says:

Less democratic by the hour
I support the Real Democracy Movement as the term “democracy” has become meaningless when used by Western governments who, by their actions, become less democratic by the hour.


Joe says:

We can regain democracy
The concept of “democracy” shields those without power from total exploitation and domination by those who possess it. Increasingly, power is dissipating away from civil society by the continuous erosion of democracy. It won’t be given back. The cavalry is not coming. To regain lost ground requires that we exercise democracy, not talk about it, dream about it or hold out the begging bowl. We were able to achieve universal suffrage, split the atom, abolish legal slavery and land men on the moon. We can regain democracy too, via the most effective tools we posses; our ingenuity, our concern for each other, and the ballot box.


Thomas says:

Learn from the post-war period
Thinking about whether and why we need a new political movement means thinking not only about the very existence of a new movement but also about the nature of it. The last mass political movement that had any kind of longevity was the alter-globalisation movement. That aimed to bring activists from across the world together in developing autonomous solutions to the problems facing humanity. While it piled pressure on governments, one of its aims was to collectively create alternatives to capitalism and the state in the here and now. While laudable in its aims, this strategy ultimately failed. Neoliberalism and neo-conservatism showed how capital and the state can circumvent protest and destroy experiments in autonomous living. If the strategy of the alter-globalisation movement is bust, what should a new political movement look like?

On the one hand, there is certainly something important in the attempts to create alternative social structures that are independent of the state and capital. On the other hand, the state might need to be reconsidered as a potential ally of a new political movement. One of the most successful political movements was the post-war movement for social democracy. It involved the state implementing progressive legislation, but it was only possible because of a mass political movement (in the form of trade unions) that held the state to account and pushed it in progressive directions. Of course we can’t go back to the heydays of social democracy, but any successful political movement will have to learn from that era and find a way of influencing policy while avoiding being co-opted by the state.


Barry says:

Change is long over due. The Global neoliberal system is driving us towards a global catastrophe of epic proportions. A perfect storm of climate change and resource depletion leading to a breakdown of our civilisation as we know it is what we face if we don’t urgently challenge the status quo.


Davida says:

Is needed hugely, world wide over. I feel it will also help people realise/remember that each person needs to stand up to be counted … each person needs to get involved to help create real and positive change. Many people have been willing to pass the buck onto others ie politicians who really do not put individuals, families, communities and couples first.


Robbie says:

The time is ripe for a Real Democracy Movement throughout the British Isles. It has already kicked off throughout the Middle East, parts of Europe, Turkey, South America – now for us to get in on the act.

Share This: